IMPLICATIONS FOR HUMAN HEALTH
There is great
variability among different PAHs with respect to carcinogenic potency and their
dose-response relationships (Deutsch-Wenzel et al.,
1983; Grimmer et al., 1988).
Moreover, in reality, the environmental PAHs often exist as
mixtures. Tarantini et al. (2011) reported
that the components in PAH mixtures can affect the carcinogenicity of each PAH,
by exhibiting synergistic and antagonistic effects, often simultaneously. This
finding complicates the evaluation of cancer risk for PAHs.
Recently Cioroiu et al. (2013) assessed
PAHs in the lungs of 31 patients with lung cancer in Romania. Fifteen PAHs were
detected, of which benz[a]anthracene,
anthracene, fluoranthene, BaP, benzo[b]fluoranthrene,
benzo[k]fluoranthrene were considered the major components of
the mixture (Fig. 2). This study is the first to record PAH concentrations in
human lung cancer tissue, and indicates that lung cancer patients present high
concentrations of carcinogenic (0.33–31.94 ng/g wet tissue, mean = 6.12 ±7.31
ng/g wet tissue) and noncarcinogenic (2.46–218.19 ng/g wet tissue, mean = 45.57
± 54.83 ng/g wet tissue) PAHs in lung tissue, thereby providing strong evidence
that PAHs are etiologic factors in lung cancer in humans. Further mechanistic
studies of the relevant components of these mixtures, as well as the mixtures
themselves, are needed to determine which component(s) (and which when
combined), play a role in the etiology of lung cancer.
In conjunction with
studying mixtures, quantitative cancer risk estimates of PAHs are highly
uncertain because of the lack of good-quality data. According to the World
Health Organization Air Quality Guidelines for Europe, the unit risk is 9 × 10−5 per ng/m3 of BaP as
an indicator of the total PAH content, namely, lifetime exposure to 0.1 ng/m3 would theoretically lead to 1 extra cancer
case in 100 000 exposed individuals. This concentration of 0.1 ng/m3 of BaP is suggested as a health-based
guideline. Because the carcinogenic potency of fluoranthene has been estimated
to be ∼20 times less than that of BaP, a
tentative guideline value of 2 ng/m3 is
suggested for fluoranthene. Guidelines still need to be determined for other
significant PAHs such as phenanthrene, methylated phenanthrenes/anthracenes and
pyrene, and large-molecule PAHs such as dibenz[a,h]anthracene,
benzo[b]fluoranthene, benzo[k]fluoranthene, and
indeno[1,2,3-cd]pyrene. Thus, it is only through careful mechanistic studies
that recommendations can be provided in support of these guidelines.
In conclusion, this review
focuses on the mechanisms of toxicity of PAHs, in relation to pulmonary
carcinogenesis in humans. To tease the mechanistic effects of multiple PAHs
will require an inter-disciplinary approach with systems biologists, epidemiologists,
pathologists, omics researchers, mechanistic researchers, and biostatisticians
who can analyze complex data sets. PAHs are a complex mixture, often with over
100 components, making these compounds difficult to study. The most well-known
PAH, BaP, is just the beginning of our understanding of the components of these
mixtures. Further research is needed on how individual or binary and higher
order mixtures of PAHs induce genetic and molecular alterations. To add to the
complexity, these mixtures should be investigated in susceptible populations
such as those with genetic polymorphisms as well as in sensitive populations
such as children. This research will lead to novel strategies for the
prevention and/or treatment of human lung carcinogenesis mediated by
environmental PAHs
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.