The
U.S. has asked China to lift a ban on U.S. pork fed the additive ractopamine,
but so far China has rejected the request. China has seen huge losses in the
pork industry due to African swine fever, which may lead to the deaths of up to
200 million pigs.1
Still,
even while facing protein deficits as a result, the country has been resistant
to importing ractopamine-treated meat. In fact, ractopamine, a beta agonist
used to increase weight gain, feed efficiency and leanness in pigs, cattle and
turkeys, is banned in most other countries, including China, Russia, Taiwan and
the European Union.2
Only
26 major meat-producing countries allow ractopamine use,3 while at least 160 have banned it.4 The growth drug, marketed as Paylean for
pigs, Optaflexx for cattle and Topmax for turkeys, is controversial not only
because it's linked to adverse effects in animals but also because of human
health concerns.
The
continued use of the drug in U.S. meat is causing tensions during talks aimed
at ending the U.S.-China trade war. According to Reuters:5
"China
would likely lift a ban on U.S. poultry as part of a trade deal and may buy
more pork to meet a growing supply deficit, but it is not willing to allow a
prohibited growth drug used in roughly half the U.S. hog herd, two sources with
knowledge of the negotiations said."
Ractopamine Mimics Stress Hormones, Leads to Health
Problems in Pigs
The
U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved the use of ractopamine in feed
for pigs in 1999, later adding in approval for cattle and turkeys. The approval
was based largely on studies conducted by the drug's maker, Elanco, which
focused not on safety for the animals or humans, but rather on economics,
including what dosage to administer to raise bigger animals, faster.6
According
to the Center for Food Safety (CFS), "The drug mimics stress hormones and
increases the rate at which the animals convert feed to muscle."7 In so doing, however, a number of adverse
effects have been reported in pigs, including high stress levels, lameness,
hyperactivity, broken limbs and death.
Problems
with behavior and cardiovascular, musculoskeletal, reproductive and endocrine
systems have also been reported.
"Fed
to an estimated 60 to 80 percent of pigs in the U.S. meat industry, ractopamine
use has resulted in more reports of sickened or dead pigs than any other
livestock drug on the market," CFS noted. "According to FDA's own
calculations, more pigs have been adversely affected by ractopamine than by any
other animal drug — more than 160,000."8
One
study of ractopamine in monkeys showed the animals developed rapid heartbeat,
whereas rats developed a host of birth defects ranging from cleft palate and
short limbs to open eyelids and enlarged heart.9,10
Further,
a study published in Translational Animal Science reported that the use of
ractopamine has been associated with increased risks of nonambulatory and
injured pigs, increased cattle mortality on feedlots and abnormal cases of hoof
sloughing at beef packing plants.11 In
short, hoof problems appear common in cattle taking the drug and related beta
agonist drugs such as zilpateral (Zilmax), including the outer shell of the
hoof falling off.
Pigs
taking the drug are more likely to lose the ability to walk and become more
difficult to handle and transport, succumbing more easily to stress as well.12 Ractopamine-treated pigs may become more
aggressive and are more likely to be handled roughly by their handlers.
Due
to their stimulated aggressive behavior, pigs taking the drug are also more
likely to be injured during transport.13 In
a review of the evidence, the researchers found additional adverse effects
depending on the dose:14
"The
evidence presented in the current review demonstrates that RAC [ractopamine]
fed pigs may be more difficult to handle at doses above 5 mg/kg and
physiological responses and rates of non-ambulatory pigs may increase when RAC
fed pigs are subjected to aggressive handling, especially at the 20 mg/kg
dose."
Health Risks of Ractopamine to Humans
The
Codex Alimentarius Commission approved a maximum residue level of ractopamine
of 10 parts per billion (ppb) in pork and beef, 40 ppb in liver and 90 ppb in
kidneys.15 Only one human study was reviewed in the
setting of this international standard — a study that involved six men, one of
whom dropped out of the study due to adverse effects.16 Further, according to CFS:17
"Data
from the European Food Safety Authority indicates that ractopamine causes
elevated heart rates and heart-pounding sensations in humans. Other examples of
health problems include information from the Sichuan Pork Trade Chamber of
Commerce in China, which estimates that between 1998 and 2010, 1,700 people
were poisoned from eating pork containing ractopamine."
Further,
two drugs similar to ractopamine — zilpaterol and clenbuterol — are banned by
the Olypmics because they affect adrenalin. In 2010, a cycler in the Tour de
France failed an antidoping test for clenbuterol, which he blamed on residues
from eating meat.18
A
study in the journal Talanta further explained, "The use of highly active
beta-agonists as growth promoters is not appropriate because of the potential
hazard for human and animal health."19 There's
even data showing human intoxication after consuming liver or meat from cattle
treated with beta-agonists.20
Warning
labels on the drug also state the risks outright, the Cornucopia Institute
reported, including telling handlers to wear gloves and protective gear when
handling it:21
"'WARNING:
The active ingredient in Topmax, ractopamine hydrochloride, is a
beta-adrenergic agonist. Individuals with cardiovascular disease should exercise
special caution to avoid exposure,' says the label for the turkey feed.
"Not for use in humans. Keep out of the reach of children.
The
Topmax 9 formulation (Type A Medicated Article) poses a low dust potential
under usual conditions of handling and mixing. When mixing and handling Topmax,
use protective clothing, impervious gloves, protective eye wear, and a
NIOSH-approved dust mask.
Operators
should wash thoroughly with soap and water after handling. If accidental eye
contact occurs, immediately rinse eyes thoroughly with water. If irritation
persists, seek medical attention."
.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.